Powerpointlessness describes the poor use of powerpoint. For example, powerpointlessness presentations have become more like a read-out-loud essay to one that just seems too flashy and very distracting. The read-out-loud essays allow the audience to lose attention very quickly because it becomes more like story time rather than more for connecting and informing the audience. By reading slide by slide, it no longer becomes a presentation. On the other end, the flashy and distracting tools used during a presentation tend to make the audience focus on the bling rather than the content. It is like having a low end car with $5,000, 26" rims. The balance of the main content and added features becomes lost.
So how do we teach students to create quality powerpoint presentations? Jamie Mckenzie analyzed powerpointlessness. He wrote about great ways on how to approach powerpoint and stay away from the dangers of powerpointlessness in Scoring Power Points.
The main "antidotes" for powerpointless can be seen as a web guide. An illustration he used looked like this:
Mckenzie states that the effort put into a powerpoint presentation should be 80% research and 20% presenting. By have more research, students are then able to approach their presentation with more thought and preparation. If a zombie apocolypse were to occur, I would rather have more ammunition than guns. What's the point of having 5 guns with three rounds? With all jokes aside, having more knowledge about the topic you are presenting can only benefit a student once the actual presentation arrives. More research breeds more thought, evidence, and data.
Other defenses against powerpointlessness includes providing rubrics and offering exemplars. By providing rubrics and showing examples of other work, students are allowed to see the expectations of what a teacher wants, while also being given many different approaches of how other students completed the work. The only problem with this is that originality may be decreased because of sampling off of others' work.
Design is also a major factor. Earlier I spoke of having too much bling and read-out-loud essays. It is okay to have extra features during a powerpoint, but the mission and task is for the student to present what they have learned and researched. Mckenzie states that slides should rarely have more than a dozen words each. By having less words, the audience will be able to listen to the student rather than spending too much time reading the slides. In addition, students should use the presentation as an aid rather than a read-along session. The audience should be able to read the slides as a student is presenting even though the student does not read the slide word for word. This is where the 80% research is key. The more you know about the topic, the more you can speak about it.
Since the design includes audience consideration, a good delivery of the presentation must also be there. Powerpointless is cut down when the audience is fully engaged and feels like the information is relevant. People wanna feel like they are being addressed personally and as actual human-beings. By having good eye-contact, passion, and an all around knowledge about the topic, the audience will be more susceptible to hearing what you have to speak about.
Mckenzie has given great input on how to avoid powerpointlessness, and I highly recommend many others to read his article to break this spread of powerpointlessnes.
Reference: http://www.fno.org/sept00/powerpoints.html



Most excellent graphics. The connection to your points is priceless. I enjoyed reading your comments and your analogies powerfully make your points.
ReplyDeleteHaha, apparently you've never pistol-whipped a zombie! Interesting analogies, though!
ReplyDeleteNice, clear assessment of the articles and the problem of mindless PowerPoints.
ReplyDeleteI love the creativity you put into your blog. I searched for images to put in my power pointless blog but was worried about putting images that were unrelated to the topic because I was nervous to not adhere to the "too much bling suggestions" McKenzie gave. So I put no images and my blog then again was boring.
ReplyDeleteI love the way you connect the low end car analogy, so impressively creative.
Creating a good powerpoint is a lot of work because you really have to have the balance of some animation/pictures but they must be relevant and not distracting. I think you did a really great job with your blog.
Story time! Haha, yeah, I was thinking nap-time but zoning out is fun too! I agree, your graphics and analogies are awesome. I witnessed well used PowerPoint help a speaker bring an audience back to the lesson. It was awesome. So that is another tool for your zombie prevention belt. Oh, and the car thing took me a while to get but I'm not really that into cars.
ReplyDelete